Used price of S5 vs S1

[pdk42]

So in light of my recent eBay problem (see my other thread on this), I went to MPB to get a quote on my newly-returned S1. At the same time I asked for a quote for my S5 since there is an offer on the new S1iie that reduces its price to £1899 plus a 10% uplift voucher to an MPB sale. Anyhow, this is the MPB quote:



So, with the 10% uplift, I'd get £940 which would make the S1iie net out at £959. I'm sort of half tempted, but it's more than a little indulgent since I really only use the S5 as a backup and it does that job perfectly well.

But - what I found strange about the quote is that the S5 is valued higher than the S1. Except for its size, the S1 is the better camera in practically every department. Strange world.

 

[Jayneboo]

But the S5 came out around a year later - probably just down to that.

 

[xaviergut]

Except for its size, the S1 is the better camera in practically every department. Strange world.

The S1 is bigger and heavier...

 

[Miki]

The S1 is bigger and heavier...

Ditto to that! Therefore, it's less desirable.

 

[Quentinquirelino]

The used market is more down to supply and demand. The OG S1 line was always less popular because of it's size and weight.

 

[cascadian]

If you're not in a rush, selling them yourself would net you a fair bit more. I just picked up an EX condition S1 and cheerfully paid 25% more than that quote. I've dealt with mpb many times and been satisfied, so only you can weigh price vs hassle for your case.